Not Feelin’ It (NEW! Award 51): 1972 Pontiac LeMans Sport Convertible – Sold?

Oct 2020 | Classifinds, Topless Thursday

November 10th Update – We have a feeling potential buyers of this ’72 LeMans were not feeling it for the very optimistic $30,000 asking price, so while this car’s Craigslist expired and with no replacement listing found, we’re assuming this car sold but we will continue to watch for an updated listing.  This one may have got away, but if you have your heart set on something similar, email us the details of what you’re looking for or call Rudy directly at (908)295-7330

Some Craigslist ads just make us stop and shake our heads, especially when they indicate the car is not yet ready for sale and they are listing their car as a “feeler” to determine whether there is interest.  In this latest example, the private seller of this 1972 Pontiac Lemans 350 Sport Convertible listed recently on Craigslist in nearby Lambertville, New Jersey with an asking price of $30,000.  Without even looking at any pricing guides, we figured this private seller has GTO pricing visions with his entry-level LeMans.

Typically when we come across a late 1960s vintage Volvo 122S, it’s an estate we’ll feature on Wagon Wednesday and not an even rarer version such as this Dark Green over Butterscotch 1967 Two Door Coupe just listed yesterday here on Craigslist in Maplewood, New Jersey with the complete service history and an asking price of $9,500.   Unfortunately, Haggerty Insurance oddly does not list values for any 1972 Pontiac LeMans or GTO, while the Collector Car Market Review Online Tool confirmed our hunch this private seller has his fair-to-good condition Lemans priced $550 higher than the #1 “Excellent” appraisal of $27,450. Two auctions of 1972 LeMans here on Bring a Trailer both came in under $25,000. Unfortunately, the NADA Guides Classic Car Online Valuation Tool is likely misguiding this seller with their current “Low”, “Average”, and “High” retail value range is $13,125, $27,000, and $56,875, respectively.  We put more credence in what sold on BaT and what the Collector Car Market Review indicates.  Consequently, we’re not feeling it and we’re awarding our latest “NEW! (short for “No Effin Way!”) Award to the seller for such an optimistic asking price that very likely will go nowhere. 

1972 was the last model year for Pontiac’s version of General Motor’s intermediate “A” Body based Tempest/Le Mans/GTO lineup dating back to 1968.  For 1972, all Pontiac A Bodies were now named Le Mans models; even the entry-level T-37 prior years found itself replaced by a Le Mans pillared coupe. While the top-of-the-line Luxury Le Mans was only available in hardtop sedan and coupe models,  the mid-level Le Mans Sport was available as a two-door hardtop or convertible with Strato bucket seats and interiors from the Luxury Le Mans. With the popularity of muscle cars on the decline, Pontiac changed the GTO from a separate series back to an option package on Le Mans and Le Mans Sport coupes only.

Here’s a 1960s vintage US Commercial highlighting how durable and long-lasting Volvo’s 122S was compared to other cars of the period:

With a three-speed floor shift, factory A/C, this LeMans appears to have great bones but the condition indicates the “older restoration” may have been a poorly executed one.  If the body and undercarriage checks out during your in-person inspection of through a PPI, you’ll have an interesting A-body alternative to drive to your next Pontiac show.  Good luck with the purchase!

Here’s the seller’s description:

“Here is an earlier restoration and still in good shape with very few things that need attention. It is a three-speed on the floor with a new clutch this weekend sporting a 350-2 engine. Great Firestone Eagle 15 inch tires with sport wheels. AM/FM Radio and the rare option of Factory Air for the summer if you don’t want the roof down. It is also equipped with Power Disc Brakes and Steering along with Power Roof. Now right at this time the car is not ready to be sold but may in a few weeks so right now this is just a feeler add call Joe six o9 five 77 four o 5 three if interested may also trade not sure yet.

Do you have a Pontiac LeMan Sport you’d like to share?  Comment below and let us know!

1 Comment
  1. Douglas Threlfall

    “NEW” No Effin Way, that’s Hilarious! How about “There’s no “I” in TEAM, there’s no “F” in way… Say it fast a couple of times… you’ll get it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Douglas Threlfall Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.