Detailed Documentation: 1969 Ford Mustang Mach I – SCAM!

by | Jul 2021 | Classifinds, Free For All Friday

July 14, 2021 Update – Despite Craigslist’s five-dollar car listing policy instituted in April 2019 dramatically lowering the number of scam posts on their service, they still do crop us. Unfortunately, this 1969 Ford Mustang Mach I appears to be one such example.  We first came across the listing for this car on the Cleveland Craiglist but now we just came across a duplicate ad with a different phone number listed (847) 962-6686. We’re keeping both this number and the original listing number to see if other ads get posted.

June 19, 2021 Update – When we first featured this Survivor-quality Mustang Mach I for sale by the original owner, we thought for sure with a $42,000 asking price the car would sell quickly. Frankly, not only are we surprised they had to relist the car one month later, but we’re a bit baffled on why they decided to raise their price by $900 to $42,900.  Perhaps they realized they could.

Coinciding with the car’s styling redesign, Ford introduced its new Mustang Mach I performance package only available on the fastback “Sports Roof” models. It’s very hard to find an unmolested and well-documented example of these first-year Mach I’s, so we were pleased to spot this Candy Red example just originally listed in Cleveland, Ohio, and subsequently in Chicago offered at a too-good-to-be-true $42,900 (it was originally listed at $42,000) currently. Comparing that price against the Hagerty Insurance Online Valuation Tool confirms the private seller has their Mach I priced two hundred dollars less than this guide’s #3 “Good” estimate of $42,000.  Interestingly, the  Collector Car Market Review Online Tool provides a slightly different assessment in that the asking price falls between this guide’s #2 “Very Good” estimate of $35,000 and its #1 “Excellent” appraisal of $53,700.

By 1969 Ford offered no fewer than six factory performance models: GT, Boss 302, Boss 429, Shelby GT350, Shelby GT500, and the new Mach 1. Due to Mach 1’s success in 1969, the GT model was discontinued after 1969 following poor sales of 5,396 units versus the 72,458 sales for Mach 1. The Mustang would not wear the “GT” badge again until 1982.

The Mach 1 package was only available in the “SportsRoof” fastback body style. All first-generation Mach 1’s are distinguished by the body style code 63C on the door data plate.  The Mach 1 started with a V8-powered SportsRoof body and added visual and performance-enhancing items such as matte black hood treatment with hood pins, hood scoop (including optional Shaker scoop), competition suspension, chrome pop-open gas cap, revised wheels with Goodyear Polyglas tires, chrome exhaust tips, deluxe interior, livery, and dealer optional chin spoiler, rear deck spoiler, and rear window louvers (SportSlats).  Standard equipment was a 351 cu in (5.8 L) Windsor (351W) 2V engine with a 3-speed manual transmission, and a nine-inch 28 spline open rear axle.

The US Auto Industry YouTube Channel features this 1969 Ford Mustang Mach I commercial:

At first, one sentence in the ad’s description has us thinking this might be a quick flip, but reading through it several times has us believing the original owner is in fact selling their beloved and well-documented Mustang Mach I. We really hope that’s the case and this isn’t a scam.  While the 1981 repaint precludes this car from being called completely original, it’s hard to find an example this well documented with the complete story in the seller’s memory.  The added bonus is factory air conditioning.  If you are serious about buying this classic Mustang, you can start the conversation by either calling or texting (312) 912-4545.  When you connect, please remember to mention you saw their Mach I featured here on Good luck with the purchase!

Here’s the seller’s description:

“1969 Ford Mustang Mach 1, original owner, only 87,000 miles. 351W motor, numbers matching, all original, 1 repaint in 1981. Factory air and tilt-away steering wheel. Original jack in the trunk. The car was purchased new in 1969 and brought to Arizona in the 90s. It was there until 2 weeks ago. I have all documentation including the original window sticker, original title, and full binder of receipts for any maintenance done to it since day 1. Runs great. This is the real deal.

Serious inquires only please. No dreamers. NO EMAILS.

Show or go: what would you do with this unmolested Mach I?  Comment below and let us know!

  1. DaVid

    You might want to check the prices on some of the cars listed, 93 Jag for 1500.00?

    • Guys with Rides

      DaVid, you do understand that $1,500 is current high bid for the auction of that Jaguar, correct? All of the cars listed on our “Classifinds” page are leads we’ve found on Craigslist for sale by individual sellers. The “Auctions” or “Reserved Parking” page only contains private seller’s cars who have elected to try and auction them on our website.

  2. Ernest Valtri

    Love that 23 window bus!

    • Guys with Rides

      Ran when parked…

  3. Anonymous

    This mustang is now being offered on Facebook for $16500. with a fake eBay link.

    • Guys with Rides


  4. tIFFANY

    Just found this car listed on Facebook marketplace under an “Irene Nelson” for $16,200 located in the Moore/Norman area of Oklahoma. Why is this thing still making its rounds??

  5. Anonymous

    This ad is now on FB Marketplace under Christine Reed who claims she is a divorced nurse living in Skokie, IL. The prices is still $16,500 and she claims that everything is legitimate because she is using eBay Motors. I am having fun wasting her/his/their time and hope that by doing this it takes away from someone who might fall for the scam.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *